An experimental visualization of the Lorenz (1963) equations is the chaotic waterwheel. It was
build by Willem Malkus and Lou Howard at
MIT in the 1970s. The wheel is a ring of leaky cups, tilted slightly from the horizontal, with some
friction in the bearing of the wheel.
Fig. 1 Illustration of the chaotic waterwheel,
from chapter 9 of S.H. Strogatz (1994)
Nonlinear dynamics and chaos: with applications to physics, biology, chemistry, and engineering
Brief description and explanation of the dynamics of the wheel
Water drips in steadily in the top cups.
When the inflow of water is small enough to drip out of the cup immediately, no torque is exerted on
the wheel and it does not move: the diffusive equilibrium of the Lorenz equations. When water
pours in a little faster, the top cups fill with water, a torque is exerted on the wheel and it
starts to rotate. The wheel quickly settles into an equilibrium with a constant speed, the rate of inflow
is small enough for the cups to be empty once they are in the top position. Either direction is possible
corresponding to the two convective equilibria of the Lorenz equations. When the inflow becomes
even larger, the steady rotation becomes unstable. The cups are filled very quickly when they are in the
top position, they exert a large torque on the wheel and it accelerates. Due to the high speed of
the wheel, the cups at the top receive hardly any water and the few cups which do contain a large amount
of water hardly have the time to loose it before they are in top position again. The wheel can do two things
now: either inertia is large enough so that the wheel overshoots and makes another rotation in the same
direction, or inertia is too small and the wheel stops and rotates in the opposite direction. This
latter possibility corresponds to a trajectory of the Lorenz model in its chaotic regime, hopping from one
wing of the attractor to the other.
Fig. 2 The waterwheel build by my father and myself.
I'm still not sure whether my son Joost appreciates this.....
Four minutes of waterwheel movement on film
Click
here to download a mpeg movie file (5.2 Mb)
that shows 4 minutes of waterwheel movement. Initially, the wheel constantly changes direction without completing
a full rotation. After about 50 sec. you'll see the wheel entering a more interesting regime. It frequently
`hesitates' between rotation in the same direction or reversing its rotation. (Thanks to Erik Tuenter for
technical assistence.)